Which is NOT a reason for the superintendent to order surrender of firearms?

The correct answer is rooted in the guidelines that govern the surrender of firearms by law enforcement personnel. The superintendent may order the surrender of firearms for several significant reasons that align with public safety and the integrity of the police force.

Reasons such as danger to public interest, mental or emotional incapacity, and bringing public discredit upon the Division clearly involve scenarios that could risk the safety of the community or undermine the credibility of the police force. Each of these factors indicates a potential threat that the individual may pose if armed, necessitating immediate action for the safety of the public or the reputation of the law enforcement agency.

On the other hand, failing a fitness test, while it indicates a concern about an officer’s physical capabilities, does not directly correlate to an immediate risk regarding the handling of firearms. A fitness test failure might reflect on an officer's preparedness for duty but does not by itself suggest that the officer is a danger to themselves or others or that they lack the mental or emotional stability required to carry a firearm. Thus, it does not warrant an order for the surrender of firearms, distinguishing it from the other options.